Community Court---A Suggestion !!!

As a jury member I find in many many cases the buyer is not brothered to reply at all, In such a case it is evident that what the seller has written is correct and the buyer does not wish to reply. In such cases why does it have to go to the voting stage at all ??.

In my opinion when the buyer has not replied to the case, the negative feedback should be removed from the sellers rating directly without the case going to the voting stage at all because the jury does not have the buyers view to consider, they read only the sellers version and decide the case. So why at all have the voting, ebay should directly remove the negative feedback in such cases where the buyer has not replied.

This will save a lot to time and also reduce the number of cases in the Community Court.

******************************* Regards.
Raj Electronics.
Message 1 of 61
latest reply
60 REPLIES 60

Community Court---A Suggestion !!!

Hi All,

I have studied many sellers; most of them very active on eBay community forums and I find that many of these sellers have received lots of negative feedback over last 3 to 4 month period and surprisingly, every negative feedback gets removed.

I do agree that there can be misunderstanding amongst the buyers due to which genuine sellers suffer. However, certain dishonest sellers have started manipulating the community court to such an intolerable extent that if eBay doesn't stop this joke, then it will loose its market share in the longer run.

I firmly believe that the community court should be there, but, be in a controlled environment. Just as there is a shipping limit there should be a limitation in the number of appeals a particular seller can make in the community court.

If eBay controls the number of community court appeals, to every seller then the genuine sellers will be benefited from this and it will keep useless sellers at bay.

I feel, per year, eBay should allow only 10 community court appeals and I have recommended this to eBay now. Lets hope eBay takes this step in favor of genuine sellers.

Wish you goo luck.

Kind Regards,
Mustufa
Message 31 of 61
latest reply

Community Court---A Suggestion !!!

mobile-phones-etc
Community Member
@real.phoenix,
I agree, however, this should only be implemented if eBay takes the charge to make the buyer aware about the feedback process. As in when and what feedback should be left. Also, this is subjective to eBay's services to the sellers as well.

ebay's services include:
1) Timely remittances to the sellers.
2) Well trained account managers who know more than selling promotions and listing upgrades.

Otherwise, its gonna make the things set for worse. buy genuine mobiles at unbeatable price.
http://stores.shop.ebay.in/Mobile-Phones-ETC

Change is state of mind..but inevitable.
buy genuine mobiles at unbeatable price.
http://stores.shop.ebay.in/Mobile-Phones-ETC

Change is state of mind..but inevitable.
Message 32 of 61
latest reply

Community Court---A Suggestion !!!

reliableenterprise,
rejelectroniks,

I prefer to get judged by my customers rather than both of you. You may continue to insult me. Thank you.
Message 33 of 61
latest reply

Community Court---A Suggestion !!!

Linusstudios,

Buyers have lost faith in community court because their justified feedback are removed. Now they have started leaving neutrals with low DSRs instead of a negative because a neutral cannot be removed and low DSRs can lead to SNP!
Message 34 of 61
latest reply

Community Court---A Suggestion !!!

mobile-phones-etc
Community Member
@Raj Sir,
thanks for putting this topic again, but as usual, eBay is not gonna consider this. buy genuine mobiles at unbeatable price.
http://stores.shop.ebay.in/Mobile-Phones-ETC

Change is state of mind..but inevitable.
buy genuine mobiles at unbeatable price.
http://stores.shop.ebay.in/Mobile-Phones-ETC

Change is state of mind..but inevitable.
Message 35 of 61
latest reply

Community Court---A Suggestion !!!

mobile-phones-etc
Community Member
I am missing Ratan.trade's comment on this. lol. buy genuine mobiles at unbeatable price.
http://stores.shop.ebay.in/Mobile-Phones-ETC

Change is state of mind..but inevitable.
buy genuine mobiles at unbeatable price.
http://stores.shop.ebay.in/Mobile-Phones-ETC

Change is state of mind..but inevitable.
Message 36 of 61
latest reply

Community Court---A Suggestion !!!

c153niyam,

I sell on ebay.com / ebay.co.uk / ebay.com.au / ebay.de only. I sell herbal, surgical and OT products only. You would be able to find my listings in these sites. If you need to know about how to develop a cross border sales, you may contact me and I will help you to the best of my abilities.

Kind Regards,
Mustufa
Message 37 of 61
latest reply

Community Court---A Suggestion !!!

@real.phoenix...

I have no axe to grind with you so why should I insult you in the first place, our path don't cross at all and we are not in the same trade, so.

All your comments are at a complete tangent to the normal thinking of majority of GOOD sellers here in these forums.

I agree that one is free to express his or her views but your views are completely out of this world and most of the times you seem to say things that only a ebay staff member or someone closely associated with ebay would say. I have said this in the past and I am repeating once again now that you stick to your own set standards whatever they be, I don't want care and don't want to know, but please for god sake don't apply the same standard for other sellers and pass FATWAH about who or what or which seller is good or bad.
**************************
CIC hosting
Message 38 of 61
latest reply

Community Court---A Suggestion !!!

linusstudios
Community Member
@ real.phoenix

I am very active on community forum and I have got about 3 feedbacks removed by CC last month so I am taking your comment personally. Those feedbacks were removed because they were unjustified, They were all left by buyers who had left them either by mistake or did not knew the meaning of a negative feedback.

I have never ever said anything which is not in my domain or which is directed to insult others.In a couple of posts where things were heated up, I even took ur side.

I expect same response from others as well. But I see here that you are talking about something which is not in your domain. You dont sell in .in , Have never used Community court. Also your purchases done in last one year are - 4 in number (those too I guess were Couponed purchases). On what ground will eBay listen to your suggestions.

Also do you mean that mark of a genuine seller is not more than 10 negatives a year, which is less than one every month. This is India, Sir. Where people hesitate in giving good to others be it money, positive feedback, or DSRs.
Message 39 of 61
latest reply

Community Court---A Suggestion !!!

mobile-phones-etc
Community Member
@all,
I request every one, please post comments related to the subject.

@real.phoenix,
No one is insulting you, neither are you. Its an open debate. You are a senior member, we look on to you for proper guidance. However, you lack your experience in selling to eBay.in buyers. Take this seriously. its not cake walk to please Indian buyers.

Don't take it personally. You are a valuable member to community court and will always remain one.

Regards buy genuine mobiles at unbeatable price.
http://stores.shop.ebay.in/Mobile-Phones-ETC

Change is state of mind..but inevitable.
buy genuine mobiles at unbeatable price.
http://stores.shop.ebay.in/Mobile-Phones-ETC

Change is state of mind..but inevitable.
Message 40 of 61
latest reply