GST implication on occasional sellers selling used items

[nimishbhai]

Due to GST norms eBay has made it stringent to have GSTIN. But I wonder why the exception not made for sellers like me who comes into following criteria-

1) Sellers who occasionally offload their used stuff on eBay

2) Sellers who do not deal commercially

For an eg. As an individual seller if I have to sell used mobile phone then having GSTIN is mandatory?

Is this deliberate move by Govt. or kind of loophole which yet to be worked out?

[oldbookdepot]

It's quite deliberately done by the govt. If you wants to sell old phones then I am afraid Olx and Quikr are your only option.

[shivraj-jadhav]

What about when one sell own personal used old items on ebay for less price than brand new purchase by auction or sell,...so in that case how to fill GST returns it will be Nil or what?,...In case for normal purchase & sell there is straight forward calculation but for above what to do? Help and Reply?

[mohammedanasgr8]

Thats Absurd... I have the Same situation.

[shivraj-jadhav]

What about when one sell own personal used old items on ebay for less price than brand new purchase by auction or sell,...so in that case how to fill GST returns it will be Nil or what?,...In case for normal purchase & sell there is straight forward calculation but for above what to do? Help and Reply?...

[offers.everyday]

you are right sir

But due to high volume of new item listing whole ebay consept has been changed 

ebay comes as a used and new item market place but the in last 10 years the market has changed and now you can see more new item listing in ebay than used . people have moved to classify app like olx .

it is sad news for used item seller but they have to comply with the government low  

[buynowindia]

---

@nimishbhai wrote:

Due to GST norms eBay has made it stringent to have GSTIN. But I wonder why the exception not made for sellers like me who comes into following criteria-

1) Sellers who occasionally offload their used stuff on eBay

2) Sellers who do not deal commercially

For an eg. As an individual seller if I have to sell used mobile phone then having GSTIN is mandatory?

Is this deliberate move by Govt. or kind of loophole which yet to be worked out?

---

Sorry sir, no point in being over smart, There are already so many posts on this same topic so why are you opening a new post for the same thing,

Your question has already been answered in those posts, only if you had taken the trouble to read. 

[avkonlinestore-5]

Sir, Kingly give me correct solution about the below criteria or give link for already answered post
) Sellers who occasionally offload their used stuff on eBay

2) Sellers who do not deal commercially

[3dcollectibles]

ebay has put mandatory to use GST on ebay.in even if it is selling used items or selling books which are exempted item.

As Flipkart bought ebay.in so I presume this is Flipkart ruling